US Scientists Secretly Monitored by Government

In a lawsuit filed last week in U.S. District Court in Washington, six current and former FDA employees also claim the agency sought to repress warnings about potential corruption in device reviews by retaliating against whistleblowers who passed information to Congress and the news media.

FDA spokeswoman Erica Jefferson said the agency does not comment on ongoing or pending litigation.

FDA computers warn users, when they log on, that no one on the system has a reasonable expectation of privacy and that the government may intercept any data at any time for any lawful government purpose, the Washington Post reported on Monday.

After FDA employees aired their concerns to the incoming Obama administration in January 2009, the agency began intercepting the emails they sent to congressional staff via government computers, using private Google and Yahoo email accounts, the documents allege.

The FDA also used spyware to capture electronic snapshots of staff computer screens, which the lawsuit says allowed the agency to obtain privately stored whistle blower reports and identify others involved in whistleblower activities.

The doctors and scientists maintain that own their actions were legal but that the FDA surveillance violated their constitutional rights to privacy and had a chilling effect on whistleblowing activities. The alleged surveillance lasted for two years.

All six plaintiffs worked for an FDA office responsible for reviewing applications to sell medical devices in the United States. Four of the six have since left the agency.

Among the devices the FDA employees flagged as dangerous was a computer-aided detection device used with mammograms. The FDA approved the device for sale despite staff warnings that it could cause significant harm to women, the documents say.

The lawsuit also claims the agency retaliated against whistleblowers by failing to renew employment contracts and trying twice unsuccessfully to allege criminal wrongdoing.

In one instance, the documents say the FDA sought a criminal investigation over a March 2010 New York Times article containing staff allegations that the agency had tried to approve ineffective and dangerous devices.

The criminal referral was based on a letter of complaint the FDA received from a law firm representing device maker General Electric Co., which complained that the article may have involved the release of confidential information.

But government investigators rejected the referral, saying it lacked evidence and that the activity cited was protected by law, the documents say. General Electric had no immediate comment.